One additional update, we are submitting today all the necessary info to pass milestone 2.
The launch will be coming very soon…
Let´s keep building!
Vottun Team
3 Likes
Quick update: the proposal for Milestone 2 has passed. Thank you to all voting in favor. Let´s keep building! 
4 Likes
Ufff, this looks great — sorry I missed it earlier.
If you need to design any tests using the Money On Chain protocol, please let me know.
I can also help connect you with some of the founders of the main DeFi protocols on Rootstock, as I know several of them personally.
You can definitely count on my full support for this initiative. Really looking forward to testing the tool!
1 Like
Great!! We have scheduled a meeting with you next week!
Let´s go!
2 Likes
Hello fam,
The work for milestone 2 was submitted last week and we got the final approval yesterday! We will be submitting the proposal for M3 today and will continue working to deliver RSK Questhub very soon.
Also, as a quick update, we are talking with projects from the ecosystem that could benefit for bring more exposure to their projects with this new tool. If you are interested in bringing new users to your projects in a better way than traditional channels, please DM. Thanks!!
2 Likes
Hi Fam,
A quick thank you to all supporters of this initiative.
The execution proposal of M3 for this project has passed voting with massive support.
In the following days, we will deliver this new milestone for review.
Thank you so much!!
2 Likes
Hi Fam,
We keep advancing and we accomplish milestone 3! There is only one more milestone to finish before delivee the project so we are really, really close. I want to thank the collective for its support.
In the following days, we will provide final release dates.
Let´s go!!
1 Like
Hey @Luis_VOTTUN,
I navigated the website, tried to follow some user flows.
I felt the website was a little buggy. It took me a few tries to validate my e-mail and login, if I choose english there are still quite a few buttons in spanish scattered throughout.
I’d love to see the website polished a little further before a subsequent milestone, but sadly this is the last milestone.
Would you consider rushing a little, and polishing the website over the next few days, before voting ends? If not, we might vote against, and suggest a round of polishing before reposting.
M4 is aimed at launch and mainnet. And since this product is intrinsically aimed at beginners, who might feel insecure and overwhelmed by new things (wallets, tokens, transactions, protocols etc), I feel the UX needs to be well polished.
1 Like
Also, I see the last quest in the second mission is to post a governance proposal.
I think this is a bad idea, as we might have dozens if not a hundred generic proposals, which would overwhelm our governance.
I see in the description you ask for either creating a proposal or commenting an existing one. This might also generate dozens of superficial comments in the forum?
Maybe the quest could be to review proposals and vote on one.
2 Likes
Thanks for the feedback. Yes we will polish more before relieve. We saw too that translations betwen English and spanish are mixing sometimes.
Regarding the proposal for governance, the idea was to teach that proposals from the community are important but I can see your point. We will modify so we acoomplish that initial goal without requesting to submit propossals.
1 Like
Hi fam,
Important update in our latest proposal for M4. When we submitted the proposal, we did some copy/pasting and we make a couple of mistakes. We didn’t realize that the discourse link was broken and we sadi “second” instead of “third” talking about the milestones. We are really sorry for this. As this proposal is on-chain, we can’t modify it so let us give here the correct text and link:
DESCRIPTION
After being reviewed by the collective, we have successfully delivered the THIRD milestone (M3) of Rootstock QuestHub. We are requesting funding for the M4 as it was previously approved. The funds to be released are $4,000 (in RBTC).
DiscourseLink: https://gov.rootstockcollective.xyz/t/2507-grant-proposal-rootstock-questhub/493
Apologies for this inconvinience
Vottun team
The QuestHub team has delivered consistent progress and met their main goals, but this final on-chain proposal includes a few small issues in the text, links, and platform polish. As @ChronoTrigger pointed out, the website still needs a bit of refinement to offer a smooth experience for new users.
Since on-chain proposals can’t be modified once submitted, it’s important to keep them precise. At this stage, it would be better to collect community feedback and, if needed, prepare a corrected submission once the updates are ready, that would keep the process clean and transparent for everyone involved.
2 Likes
We would like to echo the comments made by other delegates regarding the M3 milestone completion. After reviewing the website, it looks like like it still need to be updated and polished for M3 to be considered complete, before requesting funding for M4. In its current state, we will be voting against, but hope the team will make the necessary changes and then resubmit the proposal.
1 Like
We agree with @ChronoTrigger, and @404Gov that the web application isn’t in the completion state and hesitate to agree the grant is ready to move forward. In addition, since the onchain description was mistakenly provided, we believe it’s best to disapprove the current proposal, let the team address the issues and re-apply for the last milestone.
Here are some other findings from our side:
- For those two missions, the descriptions seem to be unmatched. The first one is for “familiarizing the users” and the second one is for “training new developers” based on the other information.
- As already pointed out, there are some Spanish words that remain in the UI
- What does “Progress” mean when a user doesn’t join the mission yet?
Also, based on the milestone requirement, each mission should have at least 15 quests, but we only see 10 quests for the first one.
2 Likes
Hi everyone,
This is the kind of feedback that we need so please keep it comimg. No problem on working out these issues. We realized that we had been testing mainly in Spanish so some mix of languages is possible. We are going to review it. Regarding the campaign for developers with 15 quests, we decide to do 2 campaigns with 10 quests each instead of 1 with 15 quests, as we will be able to split the content for these kind of campaigns in a better way. In fact these first 2 are part of a series of 6-8 total, that we will be delivering week after week once in production so we keep bringing people in a recurrent basis to use the platform.
We will inform you when our review and testing has been completed regardless if the proposal pass or not. If it didn’t pass you will be able to test before the new submission.
Once again, thanks for taking the time in checking and testing our project
3 Likes